WiFi strife

I’ve recently moved into a new flat, and to celebrate I bought a WiFi card for my PC rather than relying on a power line LAN adaptor – plug sockets are a valuable resource in a Victorian flat conversion and so shouldn’t be wasted on such trivial things.

Unfortunately, with my lovely new card freshly installed my connection was erratic at best, disconnecting more or less at random and generally being a first-class first-world problem. In a fit of internet-deprived mania I decided to investigate, the first act being to crash out a quick CAD drawing of the flat layout in Sketchup:

The card and router aren’t massively conveniently close to one another, so I had a go at modelling the expected WiFi hotspots/coldspots in the flat. Now, there are many ways to model this kind of thing – the most sophisticated would be start solving the inhomogenous Helmholtz equation

$(\nabla^2 + k^2)\psi(\mathbf{x}) = f(\mathbf{x})$

where $\psi(\mathbf{x})$ represents some property of the WiFi radiation, i.e. the electric or magnetic field produced by the router, and $f(\mathbf{x})$ is the source function, i.e. the router itself. The wavelength of the electromagnetic waves produced at 2.4GHz is approximately 12cm, and the computational grid required to resolve these would need to be more than an order of magnitude finer, which would start to place a computational demand too many on my poor overburdened laptop.

Happily, upon perusal of industry-standard methods for this sort of computation (e.g. http://www.awe-communications.com/Propagation/Indoor/Empirical/index.htm), decent results are obtained with simple ray-tracing. That is, treating the router as if it emits discrete ‘rays’ of WiFi radiation and bouncing them around/transmitting them as they hit walls.

I don’t know how to go from a Sketchup model to Matlab, and trying a random Matlab .stl reader somehow tried to use 50GB of RAM, so in the best traditions of the field I bodged my way through. Namely, I took a screenshot (!!) of the drawing and created a monochrome mask in ImageJ, where white == walls

To get reflections working I also need to know the angle of the walls. Once inside Matlab this is simple, I can take the gradient of the image in two orthogonal directions and find the angle corresponding to the peak gradient. The following image displays this – orange for horizontal walls, purple for vertical walls and white for diagonal walls:

Now, I choose a position for the router and this is the starting position for a set of rays. They propagate in straight lines until they reach a wall – reaching a part of the image of the flat where ‘wall == 1’ – and they are reflected according to

$\theta_{ray} \rightarrow 2\theta_{wall} - \theta_{ray}$ .

As they propagate a ‘flux map’ is built up which records the contribution of each ray to the WiFi flux which would be recorded at each point if a detector were present. Importantly, if the ray has propagated a distance $L$ , its flux is reduced by $L^{-2}$ in accordance with uniform 3D propagation. After 20 rays the map looks like this:

And after 2000 we have something a little more filled-in:

As expected, only a small number of rays make their way into the WiFi-starved bunker where I keep my poor suffering PC, though happily I appear to get a direct line-of-sight to my bedside table near the diagonal wall. The kitchen (right-middle) also seems to do quite well from all of the reflections, suggesting I should buy that internet-connected coffee machine…

Now we have this nice little model lets play with the router position a little.

11 thoughts on “WiFi strife”

Muhammad Rafay Ashfaq says:

September 2, 2014 at 9:28 am

Wow, that’s some good work.

LikeLike

Reply
Pingback: The Best Place for Your Wifi Router? There’s An App For That. | The Daily Swipe
Karl Jones says:

September 4, 2014 at 1:00 pm

Have you considered running this in adjoint mode to find the optimal place?

LikeLike

Reply
Pingback: علت ضعیف بودن امواج Wifi | وب سایت شخصی میلاد کهساری الهادی
Andreas Melcher says:

November 15, 2014 at 11:06 am

Hi, you can do exactly this with the raytracer at http://amray.andymel.eu. I’ve done it for acoustic raytracing experiments, but you can use it for any raytracing on 2D sketches.

LikeLike

Reply
1. Andreas Melcher says:
  
  November 15, 2014 at 11:20 am
  
  I have drawn your floor with amray. Maybe you want to move your router in realtime. Just press the “LOAD” button and use the following string in the text box.
  
  2XW47.82399999999999_66.2590396160002Z47.82399999999999_149.612Z72.624_149.612Z72.624_237.61199999999997Z47.82399999999999_237.61199999999997Z47.82399999999999_304.59952000000004Z147.03552_304.59952000000004Z147.03552_344.63536Z47.82399999999999_406.89455999999996Z147.03552_406.89455999999996Z147.03552_383.3016Z65.11552_406.89455999999996Z65.11552_439.0072Z85.75936_439.0072Z85.75936_506.80887999999993Z65.11552_506.80887999999993Z65.11552_660.40888Z210.98751999999996_660.40888Z210.98751999999996_406.89455999999996Z201.15711999999996_406.89455999999996Z222.86591999999996_406.89455999999996Z265.46431999999993_406.89455999999996Z364.17792_406.89455999999996Z364.17792_549.81688Z299.46111999999994_596.10168Z299.46111999999994_618.2200799999999Z322.39871999999997_618.2200799999999Z322.39871999999997_629.6888799999999Z364.17792_629.6888799999999Z364.17792_660.40888Z364.17792_188.8584800000001Z265.46431999999993_188.8584800000001Z265.46431999999993_116.15448000000012Z286.4159200000001_116.15448000000012Z286.4159200000001_169.4024800000001Z364.17792_169.4024800000001Z364.17792_63.23882616320016Z270.1742183168_63.23882616320016Z270.1742183168_76.32536921600018Z254.20401262080003_76.32536921600018Z254.20401262080003_66.2590396160002Z222.05842163438942_66.2590396160002Z222.05842163438942_58.5632285669024Z170.57750154631418_58.5632285669024Z170.57750154631418_66.2590396160002Z141.0496013863142_66.2590396160002Z141.0496013863142_58.5632285669024Z77.95804175751425_58.5632285669024Z77.95804175751425_66.2590396160002Z270.1742183168_259.234337287542Z270.1742183168_304.59952000000004Z229.1520012839144_304.59952000000004Z265.46431999999993_304.59952000000004Z265.46431999999993_355.70332928754186Y0_1Z1_2Z2_3Z3_4Z4_5Z5_6Z6_7Z5_8Z8_9Z9_10Z11_12Z12_13Z13_14Z14_15Z15_16Z16_17Z17_18Z19_20Z21_22Z22_23Z23_24Z24_25Z25_26Z26_27Z27_28Z28_29Z29_17Z22_30Z30_31Z31_32Z32_33Z33_34Z34_35Z35_36Z36_37Z37_38Z38_39Z39_40Z40_41Z41_42Z42_43Z43_44Z44_45Z45_46Z46_47Z47_48Z48_0Z49_50Z50_51Z52_53XS132.86408128391474_105.08792128754237
  
  Sorry for the spamlike looking post. But there is no other way of sharing this to the world at the moment. 🙂
  
  LikeLike
  
  Reply
  1. jasmcole says:
    
    November 15, 2014 at 2:10 pm
    
    That’s a great tool to play with! I assume you built it? I know nothing of developing web applications, what is it written in?
    
    LikeLike
  2. Andreas Melcher says:
    
    November 15, 2014 at 11:58 pm
    
    That’s HTML/JavaScript but converted from Java by a Google Converter (Google Web Toolkit).
    Happy you like it. Congratulations to your blog. There are a lot of extremely interesting posts!!
    
    LikeLike
ZackZack says:

March 8, 2015 at 9:53 pm

This is really awesome! Could you share your Matlab code?

LikeLike

Reply
Pingback: Does Wifi work everywhere except your bedroom? | Macinhome
Pingback: ¿Por qué mi Wi-Fi es tan lento? He aquí cómo solucionarlo